Ethicon Physiomesh Caused Failed Hernia Repair, Lawsuit Alleges

A product liability lawsuit filed against Johnson & Johnson and it’s Ethicon subsidiary claims that problems with the design of Physiomesh resulted in bowel adhesions and failed hernia repair surgeries. 

The complaint (PDF) was filed by Lizzey Annett in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas last week, indicating that the Ethicon Physiomesh hernia patch has numerous defects that create an unreasonable risk of dangerous injuries, side effects and severe complications.

Annett underwent surgery in July 2014, at which time a 20cm by 25 cm Physiomesh patch was implanted to treat an incisional hernia. Following the procedure, she developed an enlarging bulge that was determined to be a recurrent hernia.

Learn More About

Hernia Mesh Lawsuits

Cases reviewed for problems with several types of hernia repair products.

Learn More About this Lawsuit See If You Qualify For Compensation

During a second abdominal hernia repair surgery in February 2015, a 15cm by 20cm Physiomesh patch was implanted, but that hernia repair failed as well.

“Unfortunately, Ms. Annett’s condition did not improve but steadily worsened after the February 2015 procedure,” the lawsuit states. “Due to chronic pain and suspected recurrent hernia, Plaintiff again presented for CT scan, which demonstrated evidence of recurrent incisional hernia.”

A third procedure was performed in October 2016, involving robotic surgery. At that time, the surgeon discovered the Physiomesh had caused dense, small bowel adhesions, which led to the procedure being aborted in favor of open laparotomy. The surgeon conducted revision surgery, but was not able to remove all of the Physiomesh material. The surgeon also had to conduct two small bowel resections and deal with the adhesions.

According the lawsuit, the surgeon determined that the Physiomesh failed following hernia repair, causing Annett severe pain and suffering.

Ethicon Physiomesh was introduced in 2010, featuring a unique design with a total of five distinct layers. The hernia patch contains two layers of polyglecaprone-25 (“Monocryl”) film covering two underlying layers of polydioxanone film (“PDS), which in turn coat a polypropylene mesh.

While the multi-layer coating was marketed and promoted as a means to prevent adhesion and inflammation, as well as facilitate incorporation of the mesh into the body, it has actually been linked to a high rate of intense inflammatory and chronic foreign body response, leading to issues.

An Ethicon Physiomesh recall was issued for certain products in May 2016, after the manufacturer failed to identify fix for the large number of adverse events reported worldwide. While the action was classified as a “market withdrawal” in the United States, the manufacturer asked that all hospitals return unused implants and indicated that it will not be returning the device to the market.

Annett’s case joins a growing number of Ethicon Physiomesh lawsuits filed in recent months, each involving similar allegations on behalf of individuals who received the hernia patch in recent years. Over the coming weeks and months, it is widely expected that the manufacturer will face hundreds, if not thousands, of cases brought nationwide.

Image Credit: |

2 Comments

  • sharonMarch 27, 2017 at 5:22 pm

    My son went thru about the same thing but worse had many hernia surgeries as the result of the mesh.doctor said the mesh put small holes in his stomach lining.The mesh had to be removed by a doctor that told me he worked for hours picking the mesh out and could not be sure that he got it all .My son sufferd alot of pain due to the 5 hernias he had from this when he died he still had a hugh hernia [Show More]My son went thru about the same thing but worse had many hernia surgeries as the result of the mesh.doctor said the mesh put small holes in his stomach lining.The mesh had to be removed by a doctor that told me he worked for hours picking the mesh out and could not be sure that he got it all .My son sufferd alot of pain due to the 5 hernias he had from this when he died he still had a hugh hernia that could not be removed due to he was too weak to have another surgery He has passed away now and I would like to speak to the lawyer concerning this call me please so I know how to proceed

  • elizabethMarch 24, 2017 at 10:21 pm

    My first hernia surgery they did not use mesh but the one I had done in May of 2016 they did and I have a bulge there and they say it just has to heal it has been almost a year and I still have pain and numbness and get constipated pretty often which I never did before I always went every morning now sometimes it might be three days before I go and then it is hard I went back to the surgeon and he[Show More]My first hernia surgery they did not use mesh but the one I had done in May of 2016 they did and I have a bulge there and they say it just has to heal it has been almost a year and I still have pain and numbness and get constipated pretty often which I never did before I always went every morning now sometimes it might be three days before I go and then it is hard I went back to the surgeon and he said it takes a while to heal. I had a MRI sone for something else but the surgeon wanted to see it and I have not heard anything. I now have to watch what kind of a job I do and what I eat I try to eat a lot of fiber to not get constipated but it doesn't seem to matter.

Share Your Comments

I authorize the above comments be posted on this page*

Want your comments reviewed by a lawyer?

To have an attorney review your comments and contact you about a potential case, provide your contact information below. This will not be published.

NOTE: Providing information for review by an attorney does not form an attorney-client relationship.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

More Top Stories