ObTape Bladder Sling Lawsuit Filings Continue as Mentor Wins First Trial
Published: January 7th, 2009 • Comments: 5
At least 32 lawsuits have been filed against Mentor Corp. involving problems with their ObTape vaginal mesh used during bladder suspension surgery, and additional cases are expected to be filed in the coming months now that a federal MDL has been established in Georgia. However, last month Mentor was successful in the first ObTape lawsuit which went to trial in California state court.
The ObTape Transobturator Sling is a vaginal mesh that was sold between 2003 and 2006 by Mentor Corporation of Santa Barbara, California. It is a medical device which is implanted surgically to treat female stress urinary incontinence caused by weakening of muscles in the urethra.
A number of women who received the ObTape sling during a bladder suspension surgery have experienced problems and complications, such as severe pain, vaginal extrusions, erosion and urinary tract infections. Unlike other vaginal mesh, the ObTape bladder sling is made of small-pored, non-woven fibers, which could block vital nutrients and oxygen from reaching the tissue.
Following a hearing of the United States Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation on November 20, 2008, all federal Mentor ObTape bladder sling lawsuits were consolidated for pretrial proceedings and centralized in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia as part of an MDL. At that time, 22 different lawsuits filed in District Courts throughout the United States were transferred to Georgia.
Recent reports suggest that there are now at least 32 Mentor ObTape lawsuits pending, with 29 of the cases in federal courts and another three in California state court. In addition, a number of ObTape lawyers who are investigating and documenting potential cases on behalf of women who have experienced problems, expect that additional lawsuits will be filed this year.
According to the National Law Journal, the first Mentor ObTape lawsuit went to trial last month in the Superior Court of California for Alameda County, where a jury ruled in favor of the manufacturer on December 15, 2008.
In that case, the plaintiff suffered from infection and erosion of her reproductive organs after the ObTape was surgically implanted in 2004.
The jury ruled in Mentor’s favor after finding that under the specific facts of the case, the plaintiff’s doctors were aware of the risks associated with the bladder sling and therefore, Mentor’s warnings were not found to be inadequate.
Despite the early setback, the California ObTape lawsuit ruling is not likely to have any impact on the likelihood for success in other cases pending throughout the United States and there are no signs that it will slow the Mentor ObTape bladder sling lawsuit filings.
Comment by Theresa on 8 March 2009:
I had a Pelvi-lace bladder sling implanted which later had to be removed because of severe infection and fistulas which came through my abdominal wall and drained for months. I still have pain and other problems which I believe are directly related to that. Is anyone looking into problems with this type of sling as well?
Comment by Andrea on 2 June 2009:
I had a bladder sling implanted in July 07. It was medically nece due to a fifty percent prolapse. If I could go back and do things differently, I would. Now I am limited to 20 minutes on my feet. Any longer and I am in so much pain I can’t do anything but lay down. It feels like my bladder is sitting on sandpaper. I have had to change jobs due to the natur of my work. I have always worked in food service. Now I am having to go to school for a desk job. It is going to be really pricey and highly inconvenient. This slung has really changed my life and not for the better.
Comment by Mike on 30 September 2009:
My wife had a sling put in, in 2000 and since she has had it removed and another put in. she has had sutueres removed and now they can not find the bolts they put in her hip bones. she is bieng seen now in a pain clinc and we can no longer have relations it is very hard on us. She has erosion has been diagnosed with ICB, she has an infection every week and several other things from this sling surgey. we have contaced a local lawyer to help us. but our and her life has not been the same since for 10 years. does anyone out there have any suggestions for us?
Comment by kat on 9 January 2010:
I had a bladder sling in 2007. I recently had a pelvic u/s, which detected a stringy fatty looking substance wrapped around my bowel with inflamation in the area.Could this be the sling or a gquze left behind from surgery. Scheduled for a ct scan to determine what it is.
Comment by Michelle on 24 February 2010:
I had a Gynecare Prolift put in on August 27, 2007. I had to have the sling loosened because it was too tight. I had repeated UTI’s. Then I got in severe pain to find out I had scarred tissue along my vaginal cuff and bowel. Then in May of 2009 finally after still repeated UTI’s we find out I had an erosion of the mesh into my uretha. So, I was sent to the MUSC I live in Ga. The mesh was remove from my uretha but now I have to have more surgery to correct the severy incontinence I have I am only 34 years old with three young children. I now am in severe pain again I have surgery next month to remove scarred tissue again. I just wish I could find an attorney to help me. Noone in our area will take the case because they say they are to close the doctor who assistted in my surgery. I do not understand it has nothing to do with a doctor it is all about a product failing!!