Class Action Lawsuit Filed Over Martinelli’s Apple Juice Arsenic Contamination

Lawsuit alleges Martinelli’s inadequately advertised the apple juice recall and prevented many consumers from obtaining refunds by requiring they return the original bottles.

A New York woman has filed a class action lawsuit in the wake of a recent Martinelli’s apple juice recall, saying the company falsely advertised the juice as safe despite the presence of high levels of arsenic, and failed to properly protect consumers after learning about the contamination.

The complaint (PDF) was file by Barbara Seaman in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York on May 31, seeking certification of a nationwide class and a New York subclass for all consumers who purchased the product. The filing names S. Martinelli & Co. as the only defendant.

The lawsuit comes in the wake of a Martinelli apple juice recall issued on April 16, disclosing that bottles were shipped nationwide with high levels of toxic arsenic. Distributors were advised to immediately stop selling the juice and consumers who purchased the arsenic contaminated apple juice were advised to return the bottles to Martinelli’s.

Arsenic is a known human carcinogen which is measured according to organic and inorganic levels. Inorganic arsenic is toxic to humans at high levels or over long periods of time, and has been associated with long term health effects, including cancer, heart disease and death. Organic arsenic quickly passes through the body and is not harmful to humans.

The chemical was found in Martinelli’s apple juice after Maryland health officials tested samples that contained inorganic arsenic at 11.6 parts per billion (ppb). The amounts detected were 1.6 ppb higher than new U.S Food and Drug Administration (FDA) arsenic guidelines established in June 2023, which lowered the acceptable level for inorganic arsenic in apple juice form 23 ppb to 10 ppb.

Federal health officials lowered the acceptable amounts after toxic levels of arsenic and other heavy metals were found in fruit juices, carrots, and sweet potatoes distributed by various manufacturers in recent years. The discoveries raised concerns about the impact the arsenic-laden products may have on infants’ brains, as well as the long-term risk of cancer.

Learn More About

Baby Food Lawsuits

Toxic baby food sold by Gerber, Beech-Nut and other manufacturers contain dangerous levels of heavy metals, which may be the cause of autism and severe ADHD for children.

Learn More About this Lawsuit See If You Qualify For Compensation

Apple Juice Recall Lawsuit

Seaman’s complaint argues that the Martinelli apple juice recall was designed to exclude the majority of consumers from receiving a refund due to the requirement of having to return the affected bottles, which many consumers had thrown away. The lawsuit also alleges that Martinelli’s has made no effort to make the recall widely known.

According to the lawsuit, when the State of Maryland tested the bottles and discovered the high levels of arsenic, Martinelli’s failed to immediately respond. Seaman also claims that the affected bottles of apple juice failed to mention the presence of arsenic on the ingredients label, leading consumers to believe that the juices were safe. Failing to disclose the presence of arsenic constitutes false advertising, the lawsuit indicates.

“Defendant is using a marketing and advertising campaign that omits from the ingredients lists that the Product contains Arsenic,” Seaman states in the lawsuit. “Had Defendant not made the false, misleading, and deceptive representations and omissions regarding the contents of the Product, Plaintiff would not have been willing to purchase the Product.”

Seaman presents claims of violations of New York consumer protection laws, and seeks both compensatory and punitive damages.


Share Your Comments

I authorize the above comments be posted on this page*

Want your comments reviewed by a lawyer?

To have an attorney review your comments and contact you about a potential case, provide your contact information below. This will not be published.

NOTE: Providing information for review by an attorney does not form an attorney-client relationship.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

More Top Stories

Leadership Development Committee for Suboxone Dental Injury Lawyers Established in Federal MDL
Leadership Development Committee for Suboxone Dental Injury Lawyers Established in Federal MDL (Posted yesterday)

The U.S. District Judge presiding over all Suboxone lawsuits has created a mentorship program to use the litigation to provide some attorneys an opportunity to gain experience in handling complex federal multidistrict litigations.

Gilead Settlement Resolves 2,625 HIV Drug Lawsuits Pending in Federal Courts for $40M
Gilead Settlement Resolves 2,625 HIV Drug Lawsuits Pending in Federal Courts for $40M (Posted 4 days ago)

Gilead says it will pay $40 million to resolve HIV drug lawsuits over Truvada, Atripla, Viread, Stribild and Complera pending in the federal court system, involving claims that the the company sat on safer formulations of the drugs for years to increase profits.