Skip Navigation

Filshie Clip Birth Control Lawsuits Cleared for Trial After Judge Rejects CooperSurgical Defense

Filshie Clip Birth Control Lawsuits Cleared for Trial After Judge Rejects CooperSurgical Defense

A Connecticut state judge has refused to dismiss lawsuits involving CooperSurgicalโ€™s Filshie Clips, rejecting the manufacturerโ€™s argument that the claims are barred by federal law.

Filshie Clips are small titanium devices lined with silicone rubber that were first approved in 1996 as a form of permanent birth control. The clips are placed around the fallopian tubes, restricting blood flow to a small section of each tube and causing scar tissue to form, which is intended to permanently prevent eggs from reaching the uterus.

CooperSurgical, the manufacturer, faces a growing number of Filshie Clip lawsuits filed by women who allege the devices migrated from their intended positions, causing chronic pain, inflammation, internal scarring and other complications, including endometriosis.

The lawsuits claim the Filshie Clip design is defective, allowing the implants to become displaced and cause injuries that often require additional surgery. Some women report undergoing hysterectomies to address their complications, resulting in the permanent loss of their ability to bear children.

Spinal-Cord-Stimulation-Lawsuit
Spinal-Cord-Stimulation-Lawsuit

CooperSurgical Filshie Clip Lawsuit Defense

In response to the mounting litigation, CooperSurgical asked Connecticut Superior Court Judge Carletha S. Parkinson to dismiss the Filshie Clip lawsuits through summary judgment, arguing that the claims were barred by a legal principle known as federal preemption.

Under this defense, CooperSurgical maintained that because Filshie Clips and their warning labels complied with U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requirements, federal law prevented the women from pursuing conflicting claims under state law. The manufacturer also argued that the plaintiffs could not establish that the devices caused their injuries.

However, in a November 2 Memorandum of Decision (PDF), Judge Parkinson rejected those arguments, finding that the claims were not barred by federal law and that disputes over whether the clips caused the women’s injuries should be decided by a jury.

According to the memorandum, plaintiffs allege CooperSurgical reported a Filshie Clip migration rate of just 0.13% to the FDA, despite receiving information suggesting the devices migrated more frequently. The women claim the manufacturer failed to adequately report complications or warn doctors and consumers about the true frequency of migration and the serious injuries it could cause.

โ€œThe Connecticut Supreme Court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit recently held that such claims are not, in fact, preempted. Accordingly, the motion on the ground of federal preemption is, and must be, denied.โ€

– Connecticut Superior Court Judge Carletha S. Parkinson

Judge Parkinson also rejected CooperSurgical’s reliance on decisions from other courts that dismissed similar Filshie Clip claims, describing those rulings as โ€œnonbinding and unpersuasive.โ€

In a separate November 2 ruling (PDF), the judge also denied a request by three plaintiffs to establish before trial that migrated Filshie Clips caused their injuries. Although their medical experts linked the complications to the devices, CooperSurgical presented expert testimony identifying other potential causes.

As a result, the judge determined that medical causation remains a disputed issue for a jury to resolve, allowing the lawsuits to proceed without establishing whether CooperSurgical is ultimately responsible for the women’s injuries.

Filshie Clip Lawsuits

The rulings involve six bellwether plaintiffs whose claims are part of coordinated Filshie Clip litigation in Connecticut state court. The cases have been consolidated for pretrial proceedings, with the bellwether claims expected to help determine how the broader litigation moves forward.

Product liability lawyers continue to review potential claims for women nationwide who were implanted with the Filshie Clip only to suffer severe injuries or health complications as a result. These injuries and complications can include:

  • Chronic abdominal or pelvic pain
  • Internal scarring or organ damage
  • Endometriosis
  • Inflammation and swelling
  • Painful or irregular menstrual cycles
  • Filshie Clip migration requiring additional surgery
  • Hysterectomy or other major surgical procedures

Women who experienced serious complications following a Filshie Clip tubal ligation procedure may be eligible to pursue financial compensation. Case evaluations are free, and there are no out-of-pocket costs. Individuals can submit information for review by a lawyer to determine whether they may qualify to file a Filshie Clip lawsuit.

Sign up for more legal news that could affect you or your family.

Irvin Jackson
Written By: Irvin Jackson

Senior Legal Journalist & Contributing Editor

Irvin Jackson is a senior investigative reporter at AboutLawsuits.com with more than 30 years of experience covering mass tort litigation, environmental policy, and consumer safety. He previously served as Associate Editor at Inside the EPA and contributes original reporting on product liability lawsuits, regulatory failures, and nationwide litigation trends.



0 Comments


This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Share Your Comments

This field is hidden when viewing the form
I authorize the above comments be posted on this page
Post Comment
Weekly Digest Opt-In

Want your comments reviewed by a lawyer?

To have an attorney review your comments and contact you about a potential case, provide your contact information below. This will not be published.

NOTE: Providing information for review by an attorney does not form an attorney-client relationship.

MORE TOP STORIES

About 100 different plaintiffs have filed a lawsuit alleging Amazon served as the storefront for multiple illicit nitrous oxide dealers, leading to severe injuries and addiction.