Firefighter Hearing Loss Lawsuit Results in Damages Verdict

  • Written by: Staff Writers

A Philadelphia jury has awarded a firefighter $100,000 in a hearing loss lawsuit filed over the design of sirens used by the city’s emergency response vehicles. The case is one of several hundred similar lawsuits involving hearing damage for firefighters caused by Q-Sirens, made by Federal Signal Corp..

More than 600 firefighter hearing loss lawsuits in Pennsylvania state court are coordinated as a mass tort in the Philadelphia against Federal Signal. The product liability lawsuits allege that the Q-Sirens were negligently designed and unreasonably dangerous, because they emit an intense noise that can cause permanent hearing damage for firefighters over time.

After four days of deliberation, a Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas jury ruled in favor of firefighter Edward Smyl on Tuesday, in the first case to go to trial in the state. Smyl claimed to suffer hearing loss after working for the Philadelphia Fire Department between 1975 and 2007.

The jury found Federal Signal to be guilty of negligence and awarded $100,000 in damages, but disagreed with strict liability charges also filed by the plaintiff. According to a report in The Legal Intelligencer, the award will be capped at $75,000 under an agreement reached between the parties that kept the case in state court.

Federal Signal announced in a press release on Wednesday that it intends to appeal the verdict. The company says that the ruling against strict liability charges proves that the sirens were not defectively designed, and the award of damages on a negligence theory should be reversed.

In similar lawsuits over hearing loss among firefighters filed against Federal Signal throughout the United States, the company has been successful in defending many of the cases. A lawsuit filed by New York firefighters was dismissed, and the decision was upheld on appeal last summer. In addition, voluntary dismissals have been obtained for cases filed in Maryland, New Jersey and Missouri. However, the company reports that litigation is ongoing in Philadelphia and Chicago.

Tags: , , , ,


  1. Dan Reply

    while working for the Federal Government Fire Department 1970-1980, I was forced to quit my position in that department because of my hearing losses. I have filed a complaint that is now in federal District court.

  2. Carol Reply

    I am a widow of a Chicago Fire Department Engineer. My husband passed away just three weeks after a severe and cruel deposition he was ordered to attend. It truly disturbed him and I feel that is what caused him to have a massive coronary arrest while exercising.
    There is alot more to this story. I am now widowed. His death was unecessary. He was so upset and nervous after the incident.
    God rest Herbert (3/27/43-01/05/05. He was young and never had a chance to enjoy his well deserved retirement.

  • Share Your Comments

  • Have Your Comments Reviewed by a Lawyer

    Provide additional contact information if you want an attorney to review your comments and contact you about a potential case. This information will not be published.
  • NOTE: Providing information for review by an attorney does not form an attorney-client relationship.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Contact A Lawyer

Contact A Lawyer

Have A Potential Case Reviewed By An Attorney

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.