Skip Navigation

Hernia Mesh Failure Lawsuit Claims Covidien Symbotex Implant Caused Bowel Obstruction

Hernia Mesh Failure Lawsuit Claims Covidien Symbotex Implant Caused Bowel Obstruction

A Massachusetts woman has filed a product liability lawsuit alleging that the polyester material used in her Symbotex hernia mesh degraded, causing the implant to fail and resulting in serious injuries.

The complaint (PDF) was brought by Suzette Tobey in Massachusetts Superior Court on November 9, naming Covidien LP and Sofradim Corp. as defendants.

Tobey claims the manufacturers used defective materials despite the availability of safer alternative designs that could have prevented her injuries and the need for additional surgeries.

Hernia Mesh Risks

Nearly 2,500 hernia mesh lawsuits have been filed over Covidien products, including the Symbotex, ProGrip and Parietex. The complaints allege design defects increase the risk of hernia recurrence, adhesions, bowel obstructions, infections and other serious complications.

Several Covidien hernia mesh products feature absorbable collagen barriers designed to prevent the implants from adhering to the intestines and surrounding organs. However, individuals allege these barriers can deteriorate prematurely, exposing the underlying mesh material to internal tissues and increasing the risk of painful adhesions.

Like Tobey’s, many of the complaints argue that Covidien knew or should have known about the risks associated with its hernia mesh products, yet failed to adequately warn patients and medical professionals. They maintain that the manufacturer continued selling the implants without correcting alleged design defects or addressing reports of serious complications.

Is there a hernia mesh lawsuit? Find out if you qualify for a hernia mesh lawsuit settlement payout.
Is there a hernia mesh lawsuit? Find out if you qualify for a hernia mesh lawsuit settlement payout.

Hernia Mesh Failure Allegations

According to the complaint, Tobey received a Symbotex hernia mesh during a hernia repair procedure in March 2020. However, the mesh allegedly failed, requiring additional surgery.

The lawsuit raises concerns about Symbotex’s absorbable collagen barrier, which Tobey alleges can deteriorate prematurely, exposing the underlying polyester mesh to surrounding tissues and increasing the risk of complications.

Beneath its absorbable collagen barrier, Symbotex mesh is made from polyethylene terephthalate (PET), a polyester material commonly known as Dacron. Tobey alleges the material is susceptible to degradation and mechanical failure, which can contribute to painful adhesions, inflammatory reactions and other concerns.

โ€œThe polyester polymer used in the design of Symbotex is more brittle and significantly more susceptible to fatigue fracture, breakage, fragmentation and other mechanical failures than alternative polymers, including but not limited to polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF). Peer-reviewed, published literature prior to the introduction of Defendants’ PET mesh in the U.S. concluded that โ€˜Polyester mesh should no longer be used for incisional hernia repairโ€™.โ€

– Suzette Tobey v. Covidien LP et al.

The complaint also alleges that exposure to moisture, bodily fluids and oxidative or enzymatic processes can cause the polyester mesh to deteriorate. Tobey maintains the material can trigger inflammation and a heightened foreign body response, increasing risks following surgery.

As a result of the meshโ€™s failure, Tobey states she suffered a variety of injuries, including hematoma, small bowel adhesion, bowel obstruction, strangulation, chronic pain, chronic inflammation, infection, excessive scarring and nerve damage. Invasive surgery was required to remove the failed mesh and to treat multiple complications.

The lawsuit presents claims of defective design, breach of warranty, failure to warn and negligence. It seeks both compensatory and punitive damages.

Hernia Mesh Lawsuits

Thousands of federal Covidien hernia mesh lawsuits are currently centralized in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts before Judge Patti B. Saris for coordinated discovery and pretrial proceedings.

Judge Saris is in the process of leading the litigation through a series of bellwether trials. These early test cases are placing representative cases before juries to see how they respond to evidence and testimony that will be centerpieces in thousands of similar claims.

The first bellwether trial resulted in an $88 million verdict in August for Larry Patterson and his wife, Tammy, after he suffered a Symbotex failure that allegedly caused adhesions, bowel obstruction and recurring hernia.

The next Covidien hernia mesh trial is scheduled to begin on January 11, 2027, followed by a third trial in March 2027. Although the verdicts will not directly determine the outcomes of other lawsuits, they could influence future Covidien hernia mesh settlement negotiations.

Sign up for more legal news that could affect you or your family.

Irvin Jackson
Written By: Irvin Jackson

Senior Legal Journalist & Contributing Editor

Irvin Jackson is a senior investigative reporter at AboutLawsuits.com with more than 30 years of experience covering mass tort litigation, environmental policy, and consumer safety. He previously served as Associate Editor at Inside the EPA and contributes original reporting on product liability lawsuits, regulatory failures, and nationwide litigation trends.



0 Comments


This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Share Your Comments

This field is hidden when viewing the form
I authorize the above comments be posted on this page
Post Comment
Weekly Digest Opt-In

Want your comments reviewed by a lawyer?

To have an attorney review your comments and contact you about a potential case, provide your contact information below. This will not be published.

NOTE: Providing information for review by an attorney does not form an attorney-client relationship.

MORE TOP STORIES

About 100 different plaintiffs have filed a lawsuit alleging Amazon served as the storefront for multiple illicit nitrous oxide dealers, leading to severe injuries and addiction.