DOJ Sides With Talcum Powder Plaintiffs in Appeal of Johnson & Johnson Bankruptcy Filing
The U.S. Department of Justice has filed a brief supporting plaintiffs pursuing talcum powder lawsuits, who are asking a federal appeals court to rule that Johnson & Johnson is trying to abuse the U.S. bankruptcy process to avoid compensating thousands of women diagnosed with ovarian cancer and other injuries.
Johnson & Johnson has been pursuing a controversial “Texas Two-Step” bankruptcy plan since February, as part of an attempt to break off the massive liability it faces for failing to warn consumers about the cancer risks from talcum powder into a separate company, LTL Management, LLC, which critics have argued was created solely for the purpose of placing it into bankruptcy and delaying justice for plaintiffs seeking compensation through the U.S. Court system.
For months, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Michael Kaplan has agreed to continue a stay on all proceedings in more than 38,000 Baby Powder lawsuits and Shower-to-Shower lawsuits filed by women diagnosed with ovarian cancer, mesothelioma and other injuries, while the parties attempt to establish a settlement program through the bankruptcy process.
Learn More About Talcum Powder lawsuits
Talcum powder or talc powder may cause women to develop ovarian cancer.
The Official Committee of Talc Claimants has filed an appeal with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, arguing that the bankruptcy lacks a valid purpose, and seeking to have Judge Kaplan’s approval of the process overturned, so that the stay can be lifted in the litigation.
In an amicus brief (PDF) filed on June 30, U.S. Trustee Andrew Vara, on behalf of the Justice Department, supported the talcum powder plaintiffs’ request, indicating that the “misuse of the bankruptcy system is an issue of substantial importance” to his office.
U.S. Trustees are appointed by the Attorney General specifically to deal with bankruptcy issues. In the brief, Vara pointed out that law requires a bankruptcy filing to be in good faith, and not simply to obtain a tactical litigation advantage.
“During its brief existence, LTL has had no substantial ongoing business operations, no employees other than those seconded from other J&J affiliates, and no reason for existing other than to file for bankruptcy. And indeed, two days after its creation, LTL did exactly that, filing a voluntary petition for chapter 11 bankruptcy relief,” Vara wrote in the brief. “LTL’s bankruptcy filing was not in good faith and should be dismissed for cause under 11 U.S.C. § 1112(b).”
Vara indicates that the filing “fails the good faith test in all respects” and urged the appeals court to dismiss the petition.
The Johnson & Johnson talc powder bankruptcy has been widely criticized by plaintiffs lawyers, as well as bankruptcy experts, as an abuse of the legal process and effort to delay a series of trials that were expected to go before juries this year.
Talcum powder plaintiffs say Johnson & Johnson, which has billions in cash reserves, has no financial distress that would merit a bankruptcy filing. However, since the bankruptcy is being allowed to move forward, settlements for talcum powder cancer and asbestos lawsuits may be artificially capped.
Defending against the talc ovarian cancer claims has already cost Johnson & Johnson $1 billion, on top of Baby Powder settlements and verdicts that have amounted to another $3.5 billion, according to the bankruptcy filing.
In May, Judge Kaplan informed the parties that talcum powder settlement negotiations are not as far along as the mediators had hoped. As a result, he suggested that it may be necessary for the court to hold some bellwether trials to get a sense of where juries might land on issues in the talc ovarian cancer claims.
TracyAugust 5, 2022 at 11:19 pm
Rodney I first want to say I thank you for telling your story. Your role changed from husband to caretaker of your wife. I too had Ovarian Cancer 5 years ago. It has been a living testament of Faith. Lastly, I will keep praying for your family. I believe what the Lord told me...take all of your troubles and lay them at my feet✝️. God has our back. JNJ will be forced to do the right think for OC w[Show More]Rodney I first want to say I thank you for telling your story. Your role changed from husband to caretaker of your wife. I too had Ovarian Cancer 5 years ago. It has been a living testament of Faith. Lastly, I will keep praying for your family. I believe what the Lord told me...take all of your troubles and lay them at my feet✝️. God has our back. JNJ will be forced to do the right think for OC women and their families.
RodneyJuly 9, 2022 at 12:28 pm
My wife Sandi, died from Ovarian Cancer on November 10, 2008. She used talcum powder her entire adult life. Johnson & Johnson need to do the right thing and settle these cases. My wife was 58 when she died. My children lost their mother! My granddaughters were 4 and 2 when Sandi died, and my grandson was not born until 2 years after Sandi died. Johnson & Johnson should not be allowed to file Ba[Show More]My wife Sandi, died from Ovarian Cancer on November 10, 2008. She used talcum powder her entire adult life. Johnson & Johnson need to do the right thing and settle these cases. My wife was 58 when she died. My children lost their mother! My granddaughters were 4 and 2 when Sandi died, and my grandson was not born until 2 years after Sandi died. Johnson & Johnson should not be allowed to file Bankruptcy. They are worth billions.
"*" indicates required fields
More Top Stories
An Exactech Logic knee lawsuit filed by a New York woman indicates her tibial insert failed, only to be replaced with another defective insert that was later recalled.
A uterine cancer lawsuit filed against L'Oreal claims years of exposure its hair straightener chemicals led to the cancer diagnosis.
A group of plaintiffs have asked a federal judge to lift a stay on more than a dozen wave 1 cases, which they say are not affected by 3M's liability arguments.